Tata Punch EV vs MG Windsor EV - Which One Should You Buy
Tata Punch EV vs MG Windsor EV Comparison at CarHP India. Compare Tata Punch EV and MG Windsor EV Prices, Mileage, Features, Specs, Colours and much more.
Here is the detailed comparison of Tata Punch EV vs MG Windsor EV across key factors such as engine performance, mileage, features, space, safety, and pricing.
Specification | Tata Punch EV | MG Windsor EV | |
---|---|---|---|
Price | ₹9.99 Lakh | ₹14.00 Lakh | |
Engine | Electric | Electric | |
Motor | Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) | Permanent Magnet Synchronous | |
Range | 315 km | 331 km | |
Transmission | Single Speed | 1-Speed |


Price Comparison
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Price | 9.99 Lakh | 14 Lakh |
(Smart)
(Excite)
Engine and Performance
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Battery capacity | 25 kWh | 38 kWh | |
Battery saver | |||
Charger type | 3.3 kW AC Charger Box | - | |
Charging options | 3.3 kW AC Charger Box | 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger | DC Fast Charger | 3.3 kW AC Wall Box | 7.4 kW AC Wall Box | 55 kW DC Fast Charger | |
Charging port | CCS-II | CCS-II | |
Charging time | 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%) | 6.5 H-7.4kW (0-100%) | |
Charging Time 15A Plug Point | 9.4H (10% to 100%) | - | |
Charging time 50 kw dc fast charger | 56 Min (10% to 80%) | - | |
Charging Time 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger | 3.6H (10% to 100%) | - | |
Charging Time AC | 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%) | 6.5 H-7.4kW (0-100%) | |
Charging Time DC | 56 Min-50 kW(10-80%) | 55 Min-50kW (0-80%) | |
Drive type | FWD | FWD | |
Engine start stop button | - | ||
Fast charging | |||
Gearbox | Single Speed | 1-Speed | |
Max power | 80.46bhp | 134bhp | |
Max torque | 114Nm | 200Nm | |
Motor power | 60 kW | 100 kW | |
Motor type | Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) | Permanent Magnet Synchronous | |
Regenerative braking | |||
Regenerative braking levels | 4 | - | |
Transmission type | Automatic | Automatic |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Fuel Specifications
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Battery type | Lithium-Ion | Lithium-ion | |
Emission norm compliance | ZEV | ZEV | |
Fuel type | Electric | Electric | |
Max range | 315 km | 331 km |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Dimensions and Design
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Body type | SUV | MUV | |
Ground clearance | 190 | 186 | |
Height | 1633 mm | 1677 mm | |
Length | 3857 mm | 4295 mm | |
Wheelbase | 2445 | 2700 | |
Width | 1742 mm | 2126 mm |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Interior Specifications
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Boot space | 366 Litres | 604 Litres | |
No of doors | 5 | 5 | |
Seating capacity | 5 | 5 |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Wheels & Tires
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Alloy wheels | |||
Front track | 1595 mm | - | |
Tyre size | 185/70 R15 | 215/60 R17 | |
Tyre type | Low rolling resistance | Tubeless, Radial | |
Wheel covers | |||
Wheel size | 15 Inch | 17 Inch |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Suspension, Brakes & Steering
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Front brake type | Disc | Disc | |
Front suspension | MacPherson Strut suspension | MacPherson suspension | |
Rear brake type | Drum | Disc | |
Rear suspension | Rear twist beam | Rear twist beam | |
Steering column | - | Tilt & telescopic | |
Steering type | Electric | Electric | |
Turning radius | 5 m | - |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Safety Features
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
360 view camera | |||
Adaptive cruise control | - | ||
Anti-lock Braking System ABS | |||
Anti pinch power windows | - | Driver's Window | |
Anti theft alarm | - | ||
Automatic emergency braking | - | ||
Blind spot collision avoidance assist | - | ||
Blind spot monitor | - | ||
Brake assist | - | ||
Central locking | |||
Child safety locks | - | ||
Cornering foglamps | - | ||
Cornering headlamps | - | ||
Curtain airbag | |||
Day night rear view mirror | |||
Door ajar warning | |||
Driver airbag | |||
Driver attention warning | - | ||
E call i call | |||
Electronic Brakeforce Distribution EBD | |||
Electronic Stability Control ESC | |||
Engine start alarm | - | ||
Forward collision warning | - | ||
Geo fence alert | - | ||
Global NCAP Safety Rating | 5 | - | |
High beam assist | - | ||
Hill assist | |||
Hill descent control | |||
Impact sensing auto door unlock | |||
Isofix child seat mounts | |||
Lane departure prevention assist | - | ||
Lane departure warning | - | ||
Lane keep assist | - | ||
Leading vehicle departure alert | - | ||
No of airbags | 6 | 6 | |
Oncoming lane mitigation | - | ||
Parking sensors | Rear | Rear | |
Passenger airbag | |||
Pretensioners force limiter seatbelts | - | Driver and Passenger | |
Real time vehicle tracking | - | ||
Rear camera | With Guidedlines | ||
Rear cross traffic alert | - | ||
Rear cross traffic collision avoidance assist | - | ||
Remote door lock unlock | - | ||
Road departure mitigation system | - | ||
RSA Roadside Assistance | - | ||
Seat belt warning | |||
Side airbag | |||
Side airbag rear | |||
Speed alert | - | ||
Speed assist system | - | ||
Speed sensing auto door lock | |||
Traffic sign recognition | - | ||
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS) | |||
Valet mode | - |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Interior Features
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Additional features | Illuminated Front MG Logo, Flush Door Handles, Glass Antenna, LED Front Reading Lamp | ||
Digital cluster | - | ||
Leather wrap gear shift selector | - | ||
Leather wrapped steering wheel | |||
Tachometer | - | ||
Upholstery | Fabric | Fabric |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Comfort & Convenience
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Accessory power outlet | |||
Adjustable headlamps | - | ||
Adjustable headrest | |||
Adjustable steering | - | Height & Reach | |
Air conditioner | |||
Air quality control | |||
Automatic climate control | |||
Automatic headlamps | |||
Central console armrest | - | With Storage | |
Cigarette lighter | - | ||
Cooled glovebox | - | ||
Cruise control | |||
Cup holders | - | Front Only | |
Electric adjustable seats | - | ||
Engine start stop button | - | ||
Foldable rear seat | - | 60:40 Split | |
Follow me home headlamps | |||
Gear shift indicator | - | ||
Glove box | |||
Glove box light | - | ||
Hands free tailgate | - | ||
Heated outside rear view mirror | - | ||
Heater | |||
Height adjustable driver seat | |||
Keyless entry | - | ||
Luggage hook net | - | ||
Power steering | |||
Power windows | - | Front & Rear | |
Power windows front | - | ||
Rain sensing wiper | |||
Rear AC Vents | - | ||
Rear curtain | - | ||
Rear reading lamp | |||
Rear seat centre arm rest | |||
Rear seat headrest | Adjustable | ||
Rear window sunblind | - | ||
Rear windscreen sunblind | - | ||
Remote AC On/Off | - | ||
Side stepper | - | ||
Trunk light | - | ||
Vanity mirror | - | ||
Ventilated seats |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Infotainment Features
Feature | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | MG Windsor EV (Excite) | |
---|---|---|---|
Android auto | |||
Apple carplay | |||
Bluetooth connectivity | |||
Digital car key | - | ||
Digital cluster size | - | 7 Inch | |
Digital odometer | - | ||
Google alexa connectivity | |||
Hinglish voice commands | - | ||
Inbuilt apps | - | ||
Integrated 2din audio | - | ||
Integrated antenna | |||
Live location | - | ||
Multi function steering wheel | - | ||
No of speakers | - | 4 | |
Over the air ota updates | - | ||
Radio | |||
Remote vehicle status check | - | ||
Smartwatch app | |||
Speakers | Front & Rear | ||
Touchscreen | |||
Touchscreen size | - | 10 Inch | |
Tweeters | - | 2 | |
USB Charger | - | Front & Rear | |
USB Ports | |||
Voice commands | - | ||
Wi-Fi Connectivity | - | ||
Wireless phone charging |
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
(Smart)
(Excite)
Other Comparisons


Tata
Tata Nexon EV
₹ 12.49 Lakh - 17.19 Lakh
Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh


Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh
MG
MG Comet EV
₹ 7.36 Lakh - 9.84 Lakh


Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh
Citroen
Citroen eC3
₹ 12.90 Lakh - 13.41 Lakh


Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh
Tata
Tata Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 Lakh - 11.14 Lakh


Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh
Tata
Tata Nexon EV
₹ 12.49 Lakh - 17.19 Lakh


Tata
Tata Tigor EV
₹ 12.49 Lakh - 13.75 Lakh
Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh


MG
MG Comet EV
₹ 7.36 Lakh - 9.84 Lakh
Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh


Tata
Tata Tiago EV
₹ 7.99 Lakh - 11.14 Lakh
Tata
Tata Punch EV
₹ 9.99 Lakh - 14.44 Lakh